Wordtracker Keyword Questions

Mon 24 November 2008 09:00, Mark Farragher

Wordtracker Keyword Questions

Wordtracker has released an interesting new tool recently called "Keyword Questions". It's a free tool that lets SEM's find specific questions that people type into search engines.

After typing a few keywords in the search box the Keyword Questions Tool will search the Wordtracker database for search phrases consisting of full sentences that contain your keywords. We get to see up to 100 results and each result is shown with the number of times the question was asked in the last 140 days.

You can use the results to create landing pages centered around a particular question or create a FAQ page which addresses the questions provided by the tool.

According to Ken McGaffin, CMO of Wordtracker.com: "People have a ton of questions about all sorts of things. They want answers and many of them will go to a search engine to find them. By providing the answers to their questions, you’ll create interesting copy and pick up a lot of relevant traffic for your website." (source)

I like the idea, but I'm a bit worried about the size of their database. Wordtracker.com uses search statistics from the meta search engines MetaCrawler and Dogpile to fuel their tools. People who surf directly to Google or Yahoo will not be counted. In the Netherlands Google accounts for almost 95% of all searches, so we would be looking at a tiny fraction of the Dutch search volume.

I also heard at SES San Jose that only 5% of all searches are based on full sentences. Search engines often have trouble processing English sentences and will present irrelevant results. When a SES attendee asked Erik Collier (of Ask.com) when search engines would be able to reliably handle these kinds of searches, he said: "It's gonna take years".

So will the figure of 5% go up or down in the next couple of years? If it goes down the Keyword Questions results will become less relevant over the coming years. Also keep in mind that the people doing full phrase searches might not be your target audience. If you're trying to sell to the 18-24 demographic you will probably not find this tool very helpful.

But anyway, time to put the tool through a test. In my test scenario I'm trying to optimize a gift store. A search for "christmas shopping" gives these results:

Position Question Times searched
1 how many shopping days until christmas 4
2 how many shopping days til christmas

2

 

Only 6 searches? That's not very helpful. Compare that to these Google trends:

Christmasshopping

 

When I run "christmas shopping" through Google Keywords instead I get 200 keyword suggestions. Admittedly these are not full sentences, but I still get useful long-tail suggestions like:

[location] christmas shopping opening times
gifts for [him/her/dad/...]
sunday shopping
park and shop

The reason that Keyword Questions does not find many results is because of how the tool was designed. It combines your search keywords with the words what, why, when, how, where and who, and then searches its database for questions matching these keywords. Questions that do not contain at least one of these words will not be found.

Most of my Keyword Questions searches for the above word combinations return 0 results but when I try the single word "gifts" I finally get some useful suggestions:

Position Question Times searched
 1 gifts for women who has everything  25
 2 gifts for the man who has everything  10
 3 christmas gifts for the man who has everthing 
 9
 4 where can i buy liverpool fc gifts
 8
 5 what are the seven spiritual gifts  8
 6 how do the japanese wrap their gifts  7
 7 gifts for people who like dogs  7
 8 how to send gifts in seattle using bank draft  7
 9 how to make wood gifts  6
 10 what kind gifts women like  5

 

Not bad. So can we build landing pages around the top 2 questions? Before we do, let's check out the October search volume reported by Google for combinations of "gifts for...":

Giftsfor

 

"Gifts for him" and "gifts for men" score the same, but "gifts for her" scores almost three times as good as "gifts for women". And "gifts for the man" does not appear anywhere. Google also tells us (not visible in the image) that the plural "gifts" scores a lot better than "gift". So when writing SEO copy a good headline would be "Gifts for her - the woman who has everything", instead of the top suggestion offered by Keyword Questions. And did you spot the spelling mistake?

My point is that you cannot blindly trust the Keyword Questions tool to provide good SEO copy. You always need to cross reference the wording of the questions with the results from Google to make sure that your copy contains many high volume keywords.

Searching for short terms like "woman" or "her" result in a surprisingly high number of porn-related questions. I also see many spelling mistakes ("scare" instead of "scar", "expercise" instead of "exercise"). Many of these spelling mistakes rank a lot better than their corrected versions. This all makes me wonder how reliable the underlying database is.

But Keyword Questions does come up with unusual suggestions that might help you identify niches. Further down the list we find:

Position Question Times searched
 57 what are good gifts for senior citizens in a nursing home  2
 75 what do people give for baby christening gifts  2
 96 how to send gifts to italy  2

 

Conclusion: it's an original idea but this tool is not very useful at the moment. The relatively small database, the small percentage of searches involving full sentences and the short list of pronouns really limit the number of useful results that you will get out of this tool.

However, Keyword Questions is good as a brainstorming tool and I have to say, it's also excellent link bait.


  • Comments (2)
  • Tools
  • Tell-a-cowboy

Comments (2)

 

    • William Dalton

    Thanks for the posting, useful conclusion!

    Di 25 nov 2008, 17:19


  • nice gadget, but now that adwords is giving exact search data ... who need anything else?

    Vr 30 jan 2009, 05:01

Comment

  • HTML is not allowed. URLs are automatically clickable.
    * Email address is not shown



  • Using Google search
  • Christoph Cemper interviewed by Bas van den Beld at SES Berlin
  • Interview with Mike Grehan about SES Berlin and more
  • Interview with the SES panel "Search around the World" by Bas van den Beld
  • Web search strategies in plain english
  • Microsoft Bing Search - Product Tour of Bing.com
  • Mike Grehan on the future of search
  • SMX London in 8 minutes

Events

Last event

Bloggers

  • J-P De Clerck
    J-P De Clerck

    Profession: Customer-centric digi...

    Company: Conversionation

  • Sam Murray
    Sam Murray

    Profession: Senior Search Consultant

    Company: Verve Search

  • Susie Hood
    Susie Hood

    Profession: Head of Copywriting

    Company: Click Consult / SEO C...

  • Tom Bogaert
    Tom Bogaert

    Profession: Managing Partner

    Company: QueroMedia


Latest Videos

Border_top
Border_bottom

Columns

  • Lizette van der Laan
    Social Media Image

    Is it the real you, the witty you, the person who reads the most interesting articles, makes t...




Newsletter

Subscribe to SC Newsletter:


RSS Feed

Are you a bloggerFacebook


Search



© 2014 Searchcowboys.com - All Rights Reserved - All views and opinions expressed are those of the authors of Searchcowboys.

All trademarks, slogans, text or logo representation used or referred to in this website are the property of their respective owners. Sitemap