The real time danger: Google opens up for spam and scam

Fri 11 December 2009 09:00, Bas van den Beld

The real time danger: Google opens up for spam and scam

Real time search is there. And it looks great. And it works great. It's really great and I love it. This really is the new step in search. But are we ready for it? Is Google ready for it? Looking at what a couple of SEOs at SES Chicago found not. But spammers might be ready. Real time search could be a great spamming tool.

At SES Chicago Outspoken Media blogger Rae Hoffman, aka Sugarrae noted the new real time search feature and immediately started testing. She was surprised in what she saw and pulled Dave Naylor, Michael Gray and Frank Watson into a room and the four hard core search experts found some troubling results.

It turns out that with just a couple of well placed tweets you can convert almost everything in real time search. "Sugarrae" found for example that its really easy to get onto the first page of Google on the word "viagra", in combination with a good title.

It gets ugly when Hofman points out that kids could be a very vulnerable target of spammers using real time search. It was easy to get the attention of those wanting to buy tickets for a Miley Cyrus concert by tweeting a phone number and the text "giving away free Miley Cyrus tickets". And the Sesame results are absolutely horrifying.

Sugarrae_Cyrus

The post points out some more issues, but the big picture stays, as Hoffman puts it:

"SUDDENLY ANYONE CAN TALK TO MY CHILD VIA GOOGLE AND I CAN’T STOP IT."

And she is right, so right. The danger of real time search is right away exposed. How can we solve this? How can Google solve this? When I layed down this problem at LeWeb for the real time search panel they didn't really come with a solution. "It's in the algorithm" was the solution. However that is pretty impossible. You can filter out tweets based on keywords but then you simply change the keywords so that won't be a permanent solution.

The only way were Google will have to go with this is authority. Only 'authoritative' tweets and accounts will probably be shown. Or even more 'personal': tweets from your network. It's a matter of time before social search, real time search and personalized search are combined to one. One probably can't live without the other.


  • Comments (2)
  • Google
  • Tell-a-cowboy

Comments (2)

 

  • Scary that in the race to get the jump on realtime search that common sense basics as mentioned above are forgotten.

    We talk about noise in the social networks, think the search engines have brought the noise to search. The "new car smell" will wear off soon.

    Perhaps we will have realtime search blindness... similar to banner blindness?

    Vr 11 dec 2009, 09:44


  • Tweets being included in the real time results is a fantastic idea but this has opened the door to a new generation of spammers. In turn the new generation of spammers will cause harm for those looking for genuine results and information.

    Twitter, facebook, myspace are here to stay and Google made a good move accepting this and building this into Google 2.0, but it is a little early for a full launch.

    Vr 11 dec 2009, 16:10

Comment

  • HTML is not allowed. URLs are automatically clickable.
    * Email address is not shown



  • Search University II - Brussels - 28 May 10
  • DateRank: PageRank for singles
  • Teyana Taylor - Google Me
  • Google Buzz event
  • A Gooogle engineer's perspective on privacy
  • Google Chrome tablet?
  • Google social search feature
  • Is the order of links on a page important for SEO?

Related tweets


  • Steen Öhman
    Twitter Steen Öhman 11/09/2009 23:08 uur
    There are a Sarah Palin in every business and all countries. #murphyslaws
  • OneRiot
    Twitter OneRiot 04/09/2009 19:08 uur
    Hmm, we'll we're all about the realtime action. What do you think? RT @AnthonyHendriks Will the site replace Google? http://www.oneriot.com/
  • The BFF
    Twitter The BFF 27/08/2009 16:59 uur
    RT @iA "To allow the company to use the same typeface in all countries"? Verdana has Asian characters http://twurl.nl/kivr41 #IKEA #bullshit
  • Egor Lavrov
    Twitter Egor Lavrov 09/08/2009 18:23 uur
    Overnight we're in Top100 almost in all countries with our FREE iPhone/iPod Face Darts game: http://bit.ly/facedarts
  • martijn beijk
    Twitter martijn beijk 07/08/2009 15:07 uur
    thanks google for serving all my google header images in Cyrillic. Something must be wrong #google #fail
  • Jason Pollock
    Twitter Jason Pollock 13/07/2009 04:13 uur
    Wanna Follow #Google On #Twitter? Heres All Of @Google's @Twitter Accts: http://bit.ly/BYQxn via @Zaibatsu
  • Jeremy Spiller
    Twitter Jeremy Spiller 12/07/2009 20:13 uur
    RT @zaibatsu: Want To Follow Google On Twitter? Here Are All Of Google's Twitter Accounts http://bit.ly/BYQxn #Google
  • Reg Saddler
    Twitter Reg Saddler 12/07/2009 19:56 uur
    Want To Follow Google On Twitter? Here Are All Of Google's Twitter Accounts http://bit.ly/BYQxn #Google
  • FionnHyndman
    Twitter FionnHyndman 17/06/2009 08:30 uur
    RT @judyrey: Rally at all IRANIAN Embassies from 6-9 p.m local (all countries with Iranian embassies) Tehran #IranElection #g88 ...
  • Daron Babin
    Twitter Daron Babin 25/05/2009 11:34 uur
    Find out how Google indexes the web: google After all, before Google and PageRank, there were other search engin.. http://bit.ly/afaEM
  • Michael Gray
    Twitter Michael Gray 13/05/2009 04:32 uur
    book publishers, Realtors, newspapers all think google is stealing their content ... clearly not a pattern or trend at all
  • Robert S. Morrison
    Twitter Robert S. Morrison 12/05/2009 15:54 uur
    I'm interested in expanding my entrepreneurial Twitter contacts in all countries, even non-English speaking ones. (please RT)

Events

Last event

Bloggers

  • JP De Clerck
    JP De Clerck

    Profession: Hard to describe

    Company: Conversionation

  • Susie Hood
    Susie Hood

    Profession: Head of Copywriting

    Company: Click Consult / SEO C...

  • Tom Bogaert
    Tom Bogaert

    Profession: Managing Partner

    Company: QueroMedia



Columns




Agenda

» Search Engine Strategies Hong Kong 2010

Hong Kong

13 September 2010 / 14 September 2010

» Search Engine Strategies Chicago 2010

Chicago

18 October 2010 / 22 October 2010


Newsletter

Subscribe to SC Newsletter:


RSS Feed

Social Marketing ForumHow are the searchengines doing?

Button_sc_ad

Search


Twitter

» SC Tweetfeed

» Follow SC Tweetfeed


My BlogLog


Flickr

  • DSP-finish-streetview-drop-pantsDSP-bye-bye-cowboys
  • DSP-history-of-my-blogDSP-Google-before-you-tweet
  • DSP-Map_UK_internet_visitsDSP-Google-binged
  • DSP-Japanese_maps_weirdnessDSP-Google-Why...
  • DSP-David_Cameron-SEODSP-googolopoly
» SC on Flickr




© 2010 Searchcowboys.com - All Rights Reserved - All views and opinions expressed are those of the authors of Searchcowboys.

All trademarks, slogans, text or logo representation used or referred to in this website are the property of their respective owners. Sitemap